A Pendleton home invasion suspect is arraigned, another is believed to be at large

By on Tuesday, August 19th, 2025 in Columbia Basin News More Top Stories

PENDLETON โ€“ The Umatilla County District Attorneyโ€™s Office has confirmed to Elkhorn Media Group that Nathan Kielley-Toohey, 34, was the suspect in a robbery and assault Wednesday that caused a brief lockdown of schools and businesses in Pendleton, including Pendleton Early Learning Center.

Pendleton police said that two masked assailants forcibly entered a residence in the 1300 block of Southwest Goodwin Lane armed with a firearm and assaulted the victim while stealing items of value. When the victim managed to escape, the assailants fled causing a vehicle crash after which Kielley-Toohey was arrested.

The Umatilla County District Attorneyโ€™s Office said it is believed the second suspect is still at large.

According to the Umatilla County Jail roster Kielley-Tooheyโ€™s charges are one count each of felony first-degree robbery, felony first-degree burglary, felony first-degree theft, felony unlawful use of a weapon, felony third-degree assault and second-degree kidnapping.

Kielley-Toohey was arraigned last Thursday. During the arraignment prosecution requested a bail of $300,000, stating the nature of the charges and that some of the charges are Measure 11 crimes with presumptive multiple-year sentences. The district attorneyโ€™s office also noted the victimโ€™s injuries including head and wrist fractures.

Kielley-Tooheyโ€™s criminal history was also mentioned, including that heโ€™s a repeat property offender which could also subject him to a presumptive sentence. Kielley-Tooheyโ€™s bail was set at $300,000. If bail is met and heโ€™s released heโ€™s required to have no contact with the victim and not possess firearms. As of Monday evening, he was still shown on the Umatilla County Jail roster.