Judge grants treatment alternative, 1-year jail term in Walla Walla child sex abuse case

By on Thursday, November 19th, 2026 in Columbia Basin News Columbia Basin Top Stories

WALLA WALLA — A 34-year-old Walla Walla man who sexually abused children as a teenager was sentenced Wednesday to five years of community-based treatment and 12 months in jail after a judge granted a sentencing alternative over victims’ objections.

Walla Walla County Superior Court Judge Brandon L. Johnson sentenced Andrew John Sutherland under Washington’s Special Sex Offender Sentencing Alternative, which allows eligible offenders to receive court-supervised treatment instead of a standard prison term. Johnson deferred a maximum 160-month prison sentence.

Sutherland pleaded guilty in June to first-degree rape of a child and first-degree child molestation. Having been in custody since June 17, he has about seven months remaining on his confinement. He was also ordered to pay for the victims’ counseling.

The charges, filed in late 2024, stemmed from assaults committed 16 years earlier when Sutherland was 15 or 16. While prosecutors noted evidence of six total victims, the criminal counts were based on three. Victims testified that Sutherland abused them starting as young as age 6, using religious authority and threats to enforce their silence.

Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Michelle Mulhern argued for a standard prison sentence, citing the lifelong trauma inflicted on the survivors. Defense attorney William McCool contended that treatment would best protect the community.

Judge Johnson acknowledged the victims’ opposition and pain but cited Sutherland’s youth at the time of the offenses, his clean criminal record since, and a disclosure polygraph. Johnson warned Sutherland that any violation or lack of progress would result in the full 160-month prison term.

Photo provided by the Walla Walla County Sheriff’s Office